I'm curious, if you have a moment PG: how much does not doing something like that peeve you?

On the one hand, such detail-oriented mistakes aren't necessarily bad, especially in people who know how to notice when they miss them and it matters.

On the other hand, sometimes details can kill you: You show up 15 minutes late when it matters.

Does someone not including their e-mail ever push you from "go" to "no go" on an application? Why or why not?

I suspect that, by the time they check the profile for an email, they've committed enough to at least try and contact the guy some other way.

Well they probably have and automated script for rejection letters. Too many applications to do by hand.

I don't think PG or anyone is peeved by it. It's just that if your email isn't in your profile, you won't get notified.

Observation: this is a time sensitive post by the forum's owner/maintainer/main moderator on the original topic of the forum. Yet, he did not need to rely on a "sticky" thread or any other kind of special modifier.

"Sticky" threads are typically seen in forums where the threads are ordered by time of most recent comment. They make more sense in that context.

One may also assume they're necessary in a forum where new posts are buried less than an hour after they're posted.

Why have a special modifier when you can just change the amount of upvotes to whatever you want? ;)

I know, I was just joking...

What makes you say that?

Well, it was kind of tongue-in-cheek, but eventually the truth would come out and users would be outraged - it's simply not worth it. Besides I just don't think PG has the mentality to do something like that :-)

To promote a message to the community, I certainly don't see why people would be outraged :P

We're mostly assuming pg would admit it right away ("I added 100 upvotes so people would see this"), not that he'd try to do it behind our backs :p

Couldn't he have just rigged the algorithms to put this post at the top? That would be the backdoor equivalent of the "sticky" post.

It would actually be more interesting to me if pg had some quantitative way of knowing that this post would reach the top (some function of the # of YC applicants now nervously refreshing), but if I had to guess, I'd say he just knew from experience or something.

Will rejected applicants also receive emails?

I got a very nice rejection email last year. Here it is:

We're sorry to say we couldn't accept your proposal for funding.Please don't take it personally. The quality of the applications continues to increase with each cycle, and since there's a limit on the number of interviews we can do, we had to turn away a lot of genuinely promising groups.

Another reason you shouldn't take this personally is that we know we make lots of mistakes. It's alarming how often the last group to make it over the threshold for interviews ends up being one that we fund. That means there are surely other good groups that fall just below the threshold and that we miss even interviewing.

We're trying to get better at this, but it's practically certain that groups we rejected will go on to create successful startups.If you do, we'd appreciate it if you'd send us an email telling us about it; we want to learn from our mistakes.

Y Combinator Staff

So how did it go go for you post YC? Did you progress? Or did you apply again?

From his profile:

"I have always been very interested in the startup scene. I have been to startup school twice and applied to YC once with Docley (I didn't get in).

I was working on something cool: http://docley.com.

I am now working on something cooler: http://tabtrick.com/

From tabtrick's home:

"It will be simple and easily to do."

You might want to fix that -- typos on the front page aren't flattering!

Fixed. Thanks for spotting it and mentioning it.

I didn't apply this year. Looking for a co-founder and just become a partner at my day job.

Positive thinking dude!

Dude I'm just worried about all the other guys!

yes

Just got mine :)

Still excited to continue working on it, though

That's more like it!J Good Luck anyways!

Thank you!

Why don't you validate this in software on application time? Just put a big warning on every save and don't allow final submit.

on behalf of everyone in the chat room who is incessantly asking, when should we expect notification (either way). people are consumed by this question and meaningful business/coding discussion has ceased.

Probably before 10 pacific.

Hey for those of you in the US no problem, it's 10pm here in London and pg said we might be notified before 10pm pt. Nails I can bite, but sleep now...you joking right!

Same here in the Netherlands. It's almost midnight, so it looks like I'm pulling an allnighter again. It's all good though, might as well get some work done!

Good man! Good to hear from people this side of the "fibre link". We could do shifts you know!

See, this is where a fake notification date for the 3rd could be useful. That way when you get notified a day early on the 2nd, you are pleasantly surprised and haven't been dwelling on it all day.

10 pm is a fake notification time.

Ha! I like the cut of your jib.

Yeah but then they'd know the next time. I think it would be better if they had decided by the previous day, so they could send all the emails the morning of the last day and not have people obsess all day long...

In the end you will either get an email or you will not. It doesn't matter when it is sent.

You will also either start a company or not. It doesn't matter whether you get accepted or not.

Most importantly though - isn't it fantastic to be worried and nervous about this? If you're biting your nails right now it's because you put yourself in this position. You worked hard and spent energy on something you cared about and now you get to be judged. Just keep making yourself nervous and putting yourselves in these situations where you get feedback and can iterate and move forward. This is our crack.

last time we got our email 6 hours from now.

It's not often you get to say something like that outside of science fiction.

I got a kick out of saying that when I flew back from New Zealand last week. My flight left around 7:00pm New Zealand time and arrived around 1:00pm California time on the same day (crossed the international date line), so I could tell people "my flight left 6 hours from now."

I received my rejection notification at 7:27PM Pacific time. I'll work on my startup anyway, and see how I go.

haha, we have to make sure we keep working on the MVP even as we chomp on the nails to see if we get into YC. :)

hey, where is the chatroom? I had lost the link to it

All commenters: please stop being nervous, it's rubbing off on me and I'm supposed to get some sleep tonight.

Thank you.

ahhrr it's contagious!

So who here applied?

And if you applied, what's the link to your application video?

We got a very good collection of links to ycombinator application videos going on over here:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1862327

My application was WikiTorrents.org itself: http://wikitorrents.org/wiki/ycombinator_applicants

If my team and I did not have a email address in the email field yesterday, Nov 2nd, will we not be notified at all to being accepted or not? I updated the email field in the profile to include our email, but not til this morning, Nov 3rd.

I am in the same boat. Not sure what to make of it. Good, bad, or neither.

  (def check-usernames (u)
    (or (nil? u)
      (and
        (has-email? (user (car u)))
        (check-usernames (cdr u)))))

or something

Fingers still crossed! Probably sleep with them crossed as well.